Will or Living Trust: Which Is Right for You?
A complete estate plan is built on one of two base documents: a revocable living trust or a comprehensive will. Here is how each works, what "properly drafted" means, and why titling matters as much as the document.
Charles Pyke
4 min read
Every complete estate plan starts with one of two base documents: a revocable living trust or a comprehensive last will and testament. Both are paired with a financial power of attorney and a healthcare directive. We call these Option 1 and Option 2.
- Option 1: a revocable living trust, with a pour-over will, an advance directive for healthcare and a financial power of attorney.
- Option 2: a comprehensive (asset protection) will, which is not a simple will, with a healthcare directive and a financial power of attorney.
How a living trust works
Think of a living trust as a box. It is simply another way to hold title to your assets, alongside owning something in your own name, as joint tenants or as tenants in common. Setting one up takes two steps: we create the trust, then we give you instructions for retitling your assets into it. Retitling is called funding the trust. Assets in a funded trust avoid both living probate and death probate.
A trust has three roles: the trustors, who create it and put their assets in; the trustees, who manage the assets; and the beneficiaries, for whose benefit the assets are held. With our fictional couple Bill and Mary Jones, Bill and Mary hold all three roles while they are alive. They stay in control, can amend or revoke the trust at any time, and see no change in property tax, income tax or tax forms. It is business as usual.
So what has changed? The trust sits there as a standby device, ready to act on a death or incapacity. If Bill dies, Mary steps in as sole trustee and sole beneficiary and follows the trust's terms, without going to probate court for authority. The trust did not die; Bill did. That is why it is called a living trust.
The pour-over will included with the trust revokes any old wills and acts as a safety net: if an asset was left outside the trust, it can be probated and "poured over" into the trust.
Two assets you never retitle
Never retitle an IRA or other retirement account into a living trust. Doing so is treated as a withdrawal, and the IRS will want the tax. Instead, the beneficiary designations are set so the account flows into the trust's provisions. Life insurance works the same way: keep the title as it is and set the beneficiary designation to dovetail with the trust. With every plan we provide a letter that tells you exactly how to hold title and how each beneficiary designation should read.
Whether a trust is right for you has less to do with the size of your estate and more to do with the kinds of assets you own, your goals and your personal situation.
How a comprehensive will works
A will is filed with the probate court only after death. It tells the executor, the court and the public who receives what, and when. If you have a will, your estate will go through probate. That is fine, as long as the will is properly drafted and your family is ready for probate.
What "properly drafted" means
- The right people are named, including successors. If the first executor cannot serve and none is named, the family goes to court.
- The right powers are granted, for example to deal with a business. A power missing from the will has to be sought from the court.
- Bond and inventory are drafted around, so your family does not pay for a bond or file an inventory of what you own on the public record.
- Witness paperwork is attached. In many states a will cannot be probated until the witnesses sign an interrogatory. We have witnesses sign it when you sign your will, so your family never has to track them down.
- It achieves your objectives. Protection from taxes, long-term care costs or a beneficiary's divorce must be in place before death. Nothing can be added afterwards.
Being ready for probate
Being ready means your family can find what you own, how it is titled and what it is worth. We give every client simple homework for this. It also means titling is correct. Joint tenancy passes an asset straight to the survivor, and joint tenancy trumps a will. If Bill's will leaves his assets to Mary behind a firewall protected from long-term care costs, but they hold everything jointly, the assets go to Mary outright and never pass through the protective provisions. If Mary then has a stroke, long-term care costs can consume the estate. Beneficiary designations must dovetail with the plan in the same way.
Signs your will needs updating
- It is more than five years old.
- You have a large IRA or retirement account.
- Your marital status has changed, or a child has been born or has died. Some life events automatically revoke a will.
- Your estate has grown.
- You want to protect a beneficiary from long-term care costs or a divorce.
Watch the free workshop
Our 16-minute Family Wealth Protection Workshop shows why documents alone are not a plan, and how coordinating them protects your family. It is free: register and watch the workshop.
This article is general information drawn from our Masterclass. It is not legal advice for your situation, and reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship.
Talk it through with us
Which base document suits you depends on your assets and goals, which is what we work out together in a consultation. Make an appointment and our scheduling coordinator will arrange a time to meet, or call 770-507-2500.
Make an appointmentRelated articles
All articles
Living Probate, Death Probate and Taxes: A Case Study
Through one fictional couple, Bill and Mary Jones, we follow what happens when a simple will meets a stroke, a death and a retirement account, and where probate costs, time and taxes come from.
4 min read

Keeping Your Estate Plan Current: Our Annual Maintenance Plan
An estate plan left in a drawer falls out of date as the law and your life change. Our Annual Maintenance Plan is a yearly system for keeping it working the way you intended.
2 min read

What Is Your Greatest Financial Fear?
Most families say their greatest financial fear is running out of money. The better question is what would cause it, and why so many of those risks go unaddressed when the professionals involved never work together.
2 min read
