Living Probate, Death Probate and Taxes: A Case Study
Through one fictional couple, Bill and Mary Jones, we follow what happens when a simple will meets a stroke, a death and a retirement account, and where probate costs, time and taxes come from.
Charles Pyke
4 min read
The clearest way to see how probate and taxes affect a family is to follow one family through them. Meet Bill and Mary Jones, a fictional couple from our Masterclass. They never thought of their estate as large until they added it up: life insurance, a paid-off house, IRAs and 401(k)s, cash and investment accounts. The total was one million dollars. They have two adult children: Susan, who has always been dependable, and John, who lives on the beach and would need some care in how an inheritance reaches him.
The principles apply whether you are married, single, widowed or divorced.
Their planning options
Bill and Mary could try to spend it all, though the timing is hard to get right. They could die intestate, with no will or trust, leaving everything to the law and the court. And even people who do have a will can end up intestate, because certain life events automatically revoke a will. That is why a plan has to be kept current, not just done once.
Their real choices are three:
- Joint tenancy. When one owner dies, the asset passes automatically to the survivor. Convenient, but it can be a dangerous way to hold title if you want to protect assets from long-term care costs or other life events.
- A last will and testament. An excellent tool, provided it is properly drafted and fits your situation. For example, running certain assets through a will can accelerate the income tax on those assets in the year of death.
- A living trust. A complete will substitute that names who handles the estate and who receives it. The main difference is that assets retitled into the trust avoid probate.
Living probate
After a health scare, Bill and Mary ask the real estate attorney who handled their daughter's refinance for a simple will: everything to each other, then equally to the children. Six months later Bill has a stroke.
Most people assume Bill died. We all expect to die, but few of us expect to become incapacitated. Someone turning 65 today has almost a 70% chance of needing some type of long-term care, according to the federal Administration for Community Living.
Who now has legal authority to make Bill's healthcare and financial decisions? Bill and Mary only had a will, and a will takes effect only at death. Without the right documents signed before an incapacity, the family is forced into what we call living probate: a conservatorship or guardianship proceeding. It is public, it declares a person incompetent, the court decides who will make decisions, and it is time-consuming and can be unnecessarily expensive. It is also easy to avoid with the right documents in place beforehand.
Death probate
A few years later Bill dies. Death probate is the court process of moving title out of the deceased person's name into the names of the intended beneficiaries. The court also resolves disputes, sees that creditors are paid, and requires assets to be inventoried and valued before distribution.
It does not have to be terrible, but without planning it can be slow and costly:
- Executor or administrator commissions are commonly a percentage of the gross value of the probate estate, not the equity. On a $450,000 property with a $300,000 mortgage, the fee is figured on $450,000.
- Cost and time. A national survey our firm took part in found the average cost of administering an estate was about 7.4% of the gross probate estate, and administration took anywhere from nine to 24 months.
- Public record. Anyone can read a probate file, which can show who the heirs are, where they live and, if an inventory is filed, what they receive. You can draft around that.
- Multiple probates. A Georgia resident who owns property in Alabama or Florida may need probate in each state, with separate fees. Planned for in advance, this can be avoided.
Then, when Mary dies ten years later, the assets go through the same process again. Filing fees, a creditors' notice in the county paper and possibly a bond are added to the executor's commission. Most of our clients never have to post a bond, because we either avoid probate or draft the will so a bond is not required. A will that is silent on the point usually means a bond, or a petition to waive it.
Taxes
Most families pay income tax at a combined federal and state rate somewhere between 10% and 44%, followed by sales, gasoline and property taxes on what is left. Then there is the estate tax. Under current law, the Masterclass notes, an estate worth less than $15 million does not need to worry about federal estate tax; above that, 40% of the excess is owed, and there are ways to eliminate, minimize or prepare for it.
For most families the more immediate tax is income tax on retirement accounts. Bill's $400,000 401(k) is not $400,000 Mary can live on: every withdrawal is taxed. At the same time her household income falls, because one Social Security check stops and a pension may or may not continue. Mary has lost her husband, has to handle every legal, financial and tax issue herself, and has less income and less money than she expected. Her fear is the one most families name: running out of money.
That is why estate planning, tax planning, retirement planning and income planning have to be coordinated.
Watch the free workshop
Our 16-minute Family Wealth Protection Workshop shows why documents alone are not a plan, and how coordinating them protects your family. It is free: register and watch the workshop.
Sources
Likelihood of long-term care: Administration for Community Living, “How Much Care Will You Need?”
This article is general information drawn from our Masterclass. It is not legal advice for your situation, and reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship.
Talk it through with us
If you would like help reviewing your plan or discussing your options, Make an appointment and our scheduling coordinator will arrange a time to meet, or call 770-507-2500.
Make an appointmentRelated articles
All articles
Will or Living Trust: Which Is Right for You?
A complete estate plan is built on one of two base documents: a revocable living trust or a comprehensive will. Here is how each works, what "properly drafted" means, and why titling matters as much as the document.
4 min read

Keeping Your Estate Plan Current: Our Annual Maintenance Plan
An estate plan left in a drawer falls out of date as the law and your life change. Our Annual Maintenance Plan is a yearly system for keeping it working the way you intended.
2 min read

What Is Your Greatest Financial Fear?
Most families say their greatest financial fear is running out of money. The better question is what would cause it, and why so many of those risks go unaddressed when the professionals involved never work together.
2 min read
